TL;DR
Get business pricing on garage and car supplies
- Business-only prices and quantity discounts
- Tax-exempt purchasing
- Multiple users, one account, clear invoices
The Drive reported that a California-based producer bought a 2007 Toyota Yaris for $2,300 for a three-week, roughly 3,000-mile Midwest road trip, after its price came in $300 below a round-trip rental quote. Repairs and parts erased that apparent saving, and a clutch slave-cylinder failure interrupted a track session. The final bill was not specified, so the account illustrates one buyer’s experience rather than a general cost comparison.
A used 2007 Toyota Yaris that appeared to cost $300 less than a three-week rental ended up costing its buyer more after repairs, according to a report by The Drive. The California-based producer bought the $2,300 hatchback for a roughly 3,000-mile Midwest road trip that also included track driving, making the episode a cautionary example of how a low purchase price can change once an older car needs work.
The producer, identified as Joey, was planning a road trip around the Midwest that would end with time at a racetrack. The report says rental companies’ restrictions on track use were a problem, so he bought the five-speed Yaris from the yard of a friend’s shop in Kentucky. At $2,300, its listed price was $300 below the cost of a round-trip rental, according to the account.
The car had been sitting in a field and was not in perfect condition. The buyer spent the apparent $300 saving on the car and drove several hundred miles around the Midwest while sourcing parts. The source does not provide a full itemized repair bill, so it is not possible to calculate the car’s final cost or compare it precisely with the rental quote.
At Virginia International Raceway, the Yaris completed only one track session before its clutch slave cylinder expelled fluid, leaving the driver unable to shift. After the car was towed off the track, the report says Joey used hood bolts in a makeshift repair and resumed the trip. The account says he spent quite a bit more than planned, but does not state the final total or whether the car completed all remaining miles without further trouble.
The Purchase Price Was Only the Start
The comparison matters to people deciding whether to rent for an extended trip or buy an inexpensive used car: the sticker price is not the whole cost. A purchase may also bring registration, insurance, taxes, inspection, maintenance and repair expenses, while a rental quote may have its own mileage limits, fees and restrictions. The source gives too little detail to quantify those costs across either option.
Here, the choice also involved what the vehicle would be used for. Joey wanted to drive the car on track, a use that the report says rental companies tend to make difficult. Buying the Yaris gave him control over that use and left him with a vehicle afterward. He also intended to turn it into a regional runabout and time-attack project. Those future uses could make the purchase worthwhile to him, but they do not change the report’s stated result for the original comparison: this particular car was not cheaper than renting.
For readers weighing a similar decision, the episode is a case study, not a universal rule. A newer or better-maintained used car might need less immediate work; another cheap car might need much more. Without the rental agreement, repair receipts, ownership costs and resale value, the final difference cannot be independently established.
Products Worth Considering
Chemical Guys 14-Piece Arsenal Builder Car Wash Kit with Foam Blaster
Chemical Guys 10-Piece Car Wash Kit with Foam Gun
Chemical Guys HOL123 Car Cleaning Kit – 14-Item Interior & Exterior Detailing Set
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
A Long Rental Versus a Cheap Hatchback
The question behind the report is whether buying makes financial sense when a car is needed for a longer period, rather than renting a vehicle occasionally for a specific task. Joey’s trip combined ordinary road use with a track visit, creating a practical reason to avoid a rental beyond the initial price comparison. The Yaris’s low purchase price made the alternative look attractive, but its condition meant that the comparison quickly included repairs and parts.
The report describes the buyer’s longer-term plan as part of the calculation: he hoped to keep the car as a regional runabout and develop it as a time-attack car. That is different from buying a vehicle solely for one trip and selling it afterward. The source does not say whether he later sold the Yaris, how much it was worth, or what its ongoing costs were. Those unanswered details matter when comparing total ownership cost with a rental.
The Final Cost Is Not Reported
The source does not state the Yaris’s total purchase and repair costs, the exact rental price, or the rental’s mileage allowance, insurance terms and other fees. It also does not provide receipts, the car’s condition before purchase, or a resale value. The report therefore supports the conclusion that Joey’s costs exceeded his original budget and that this particular purchase was not cheaper than the rental, but it does not establish the size of the difference.
It is also unclear how the car performed over the rest of the trip or what repairs it needed afterward. The account describes a clutch slave-cylinder failure during one track session and a makeshift fix after towing, but does not detail any later mechanical issues. No broader comparison across used cars or rental companies is provided.
Ownership Costs Will Shape the Verdict
The source presents Joey’s longer-term intention as turning the Yaris into a regional runabout and time-attack car, but does not report a later update on whether that plan succeeded. A fuller financial comparison would need the final repair bill, ongoing maintenance and ownership expenses, any rental fees beyond the quoted price, and the car’s value after the trip.
For anyone making the same choice, the next step is to compare the full costs for their own circumstances rather than the purchase price alone. A rental quote should be checked for trip length, mileage and permitted use. A prospective used-car buyer would need to account for the vehicle’s condition and likely repairs, as well as the costs of keeping or selling it after the trip. The report does not provide enough information to say which option is generally cheaper.
Key Questions
Was the used Yaris cheaper than the rental?
No. The Drive’s account says Joey spent more than his original budget after buying the Yaris and concludes that this car was not cheaper than the rental. It does not provide the final bill or exact difference.
How much did the Yaris cost to buy?
The listed price for the 2007 Toyota Yaris was $2,300. The report says that was $300 less than a round-trip rental, before the additional spending on parts and repairs.
Why did Joey buy instead of rent?
His three-week trip included track driving, which the report says can be problematic with rental companies. Buying the Yaris also gave him a car he intended to use afterward as a regional runabout and track project.
What went wrong with the car?
The Yaris had been sitting in a field and needed parts. During a track session at Virginia International Raceway, its clutch slave cylinder expelled fluid, leaving Joey unable to shift. The source does not list all repairs or later problems.
Can this story show whether buying is generally cheaper than renting?
No. It describes one car and one trip, without a final cost breakdown or full rental terms. The outcome may differ depending on the used car’s condition, trip length, rental restrictions and the vehicle’s value after the trip.
Source: thedrive.com
